The topic was a more technical one and related to the 4way thriller between Golden Knights and Aerodyne French Girls at the World Cup 2013. The exciting competition between the world's two top teams in the female 4way category was covered with several stories, and the tie-breaker in Banja Luka received additional attention on 19 August 2013.
The Blue Skies Mag article went deeper into the same topic and provided additional food for thought. The events at the World Cup and the following discussion of the rules may lead into some changes in the near future. It could become a sudden death situation.
The recent and most discussed competition was the jump-off between Aerodyne French Girls and Golden Knights for gold medals in women's 4-way at the World Cup 2013 in Banja Luka. They were tied in first place after eight rounds and then matched their scores in the two following rounds.
The jump-off Round 11 did not change the situation, and the IPC officials had to dig deeper to find out who would get the gold medals. Current IPC rules determine the winner by finding the highest scoring round in the whole competition; at this World Cup France won with their 27-pointer in Round 2, which had been completed a few days before the jump-off round.
|World Cup 2013||Rd. 1||Rd. 2||Rd. 3||Rd. 4||Rd. 5||Rd. 6||Rd. 7||Rd. 8||Rd. 9||Rd. 10||Rd. 11||T.|
|1||Aerodyne French Girls||21||27||16(-2)||18||20(-1)||17||17(-2)||23||24(-1)||20||17||220|
The tied teams are performing the same sequence at any time of the meet and always try to complete as many scoring formations in the 35-second working time as possible. There is always the last formation within working time for each team.
That's literally the last action of the competition for all teams, including the two or more tied teams. The first team may have completed the last scoring formation at 34.78 seconds, and the other team at 34.95 seconds. The first team was obviously a little bit faster/better at the very end of the competition and would be the winner with this tie-breaking procedure.
Rd. 10 Aerodyne French Girls
Rd. 10 Golden Knights
Now the hobby judges can get out their stop watches and review the videos of the Golden Knights and the French Girls one more time, or a few more times. It was an extremely exciting finish in Banja Luke, and both teams deserved the gold. However, there can be only one winner, and the French team had the upper hand with the 27-pointer in Round 2, according to the current tie-breaking rules. Sudden Death might be up at the next IPC event...
Several participants questioned whether the score for Round 2 was the proper and fair factor to break the tie between the two teams in Banja Luka — and for any other competition. The jump-off itself as the first level of the tie-breaking procedure was never in doubt and is fully supported by everybody.
As usual, I like to look around at other sports instead of re-inventing wheels, or rules. "Sudden death" it is called when ice-hockey teams break their tie in overtime. Everything that happened before doesn't matter any longer. The same counts for any other overtime rules in other sports (basketball, football, soccer, etc.) Golfers play additional holes and have to forget what happened earlier.
The jump-off in formation skydiving competition follows the same rule and the same idea: The performance of a team at the jump-off point in time is the deciding factor. In other words, the better team at the last point in time should be the winner.
Officials, teams and competitors were discussing other ways to break a tie, and the current rules actually have a better way when it comes to our third level of the tie-breaking procedure. If the teams also matched their highest score of the meet (second level), then it is time to look for the higher score per round in reverse order.
In REVERSE ORDER — that's the difference. The better team at the end of the competition — at this "decisive point in time" — should be the winner, just as in other sports.